Are sleeping pills safe? The risks of prescription and over-the-counter sleep aids, and how to use t

Publish date: 2024-08-03
2020-04-20T21:03:48Z

Sleep problems are common. According to the National Sleep Foundation, 30% to 40% of US adults report experiencing symptoms of insomnia, and 4% of adults over the age of 20 use prescription sleep aids.

But you don't necessarily need a prescription. There are also over-the-counter sleeping aids. Here's what you need to know about both types of sleeping pills and their risks, side effects, and safety.

Prescription sleeping pills

Prescription sleep aids are usually reserved for those with diagnosed insomnia. 

Insomnia is defined as trouble falling asleep, staying asleep, or waking up too early for at least three nights per week over a period of three months, says Alex Dimitriu, MD, founder of Menlo Park Psychiatry & Sleep Medicine. 

Other factors that can affect sleep, such as depression, anxiety, alcohol and substance use, or pain and medical problems, have to be absent to make a clear diagnosis of insomnia, Dimitriu says.

If you have addressed other possible medical conditions that can make it difficult to sleep, but still find that insomnia interferes with your daily life, a prescription or over-the-counter sleep aid could help get you back on track. 

Prescription sleeping pills, known as sedative hypnotics, fall into three categories:

Are sleeping pills safe? 

Sleeping pills are mostly safe, but they carry some known side effects, which can pose a risk to your health. 

For example, benzodiazepines and nonbenzodiazepines can cause daytime grogginess, which can increase the risk of falls or other accidents, Dasgupta says. Some nonbenzodiazepines are affiliated with dangerous and complex sleep-related behaviors, such as sleepwalking and sleep-driving.

The Food and Drug Administration (FDA) mandates label warnings on three nonbenzodiazepine drugs — eszopiclone, zaleplon and zolpidem — because of "rare but serious injuries and deaths" from sleep-walking or sleep-driving when taking these medications. According to the FDA, these drugs have been connected to 20 reported deaths and 46 non-fatal but serious injuries.

Overall, the safety and effectiveness of sleeping pills depends greatly on the individual. 

"I think this is where you have to tailor the medication with your physician to your situation," Dasgupta says. "It really just depends on the person, everything else that's going on, the options out there, and their medical history."

How to safely use sleeping pills

Sleeping pills are meant for you to take before a full night of sleep to reduce the risk of excessive grogginess the next day. However, sleeping pills, when used incorrectly or by a high-risk group can be extremely dangerous. 

Before seeking a sleep aid, here's what you should know: 

Common side effects of sleeping pills include headaches, prolonged drowsiness, problems with memory, and dizziness. 

If you notice these side effects, or more severe risks such as sleepwalking or next-day grogginess that impacts your ability to function, Dasgupta recommends stopping the medication and consulting your doctor.

Over-the-counter sleeping pills are safer, but also come with risks

Just because a sleeping pill is over-the-counter doesn't necessarily mean it is safe, Dasgupta says. As with prescription sleep aids, factors like medical history, other medications you're on, and underlying health conditions all contribute to how your body reacts to over-the-counter sleeping pills.

Most over-the-counter sleep aids, such as Unisom, ZzzQuil, and Sleepinal, contain antihistamines, which are typically used to treat allergy symptoms, but can also cause drowsiness. Histamine is produced in the brain and plays a role in helping you feel awake, so medications that interrupt histamine reception can result in sleepiness.

The antihistamine Benadryl, for example, contains an ingredient called diphenhydramine. Long-term use of diphenhydramine has been found to increase the risk of dementia. Moreover, just as with prescription sleep aids, you could become dependent on over-the-counter sleeping pills as well, like Benadryl or Unisom, Dasgupta says. 

Herbal supplements like Valerian root, chamomile, and melatonin can also help with sleep, though they are not regulated nor are they approved by the FDA.

The safest option for treating insomnia isn't medication, but a type of therapy known as cognitive behavioral therapy (CBT), says David Cutler, MD, a family medicine physician at Providence Saint John's Health Center. 

CBT helps you change thoughts and behaviors that may be contributing to your sleep problems, and it doesn't come with common side effects of sleeping pills, like grogginess or abnormal sleep behaviors. Studies show that CBT reduces symptoms of insomnia and helps patients overcome the underlying causes of their sleep problems.

"The mind is very powerful," Cutler says. "A lot of it really does come back to cognitive behavioral therapy, and using the power of the mind to help you be a better sleeper."

Related stories about sleep:

spanErin Heger is a freelance journalist located in the Kansas City area. She primarily covers stories related to healthcare policy, maternal mental health, parenting, and personal finance. Her work been featured in The Atlantic, Rewire.News, Refinery29, HuffPost, and more. /span Erin Heger Erin Heger is a freelance journalist located in the Kansas City area. She primarily covers stories related to healthcare policy, maternal mental health, parenting, and personal finance. Her work been featured in The Atlantic, Rewire.News, Refinery29, HuffPost, and more.  Read more Read less

ncG1vNJzZmivp6x7o8HSoqWeq6Oeu7S1w56pZ5ufonyowcidnKxnmJqurcDHaKurnZGpuqa606xmmqqVYsCtscSpoKefXaW2rbjSZqqanpU%3D